Difference between revisions of "Sandstone permeability prediction from texture"

From AAPG Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(17 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 6: Line 6:
 
  | part    = Predicting the occurrence of oil and gas traps
 
  | part    = Predicting the occurrence of oil and gas traps
 
  | chapter = Predicting reservoir system quality and performance
 
  | chapter = Predicting reservoir system quality and performance
  | frompg  = 9-1
+
  | frompg  = 9-92
  | topg    = 9-156
+
  | topg    = 9-95
 
  | author  = Dan J. Hartmann, Edward A. Beaumont
 
  | author  = Dan J. Hartmann, Edward A. Beaumont
 
  | link    = http://archives.datapages.com/data/specpubs/beaumont/ch09/ch09.htm
 
  | link    = http://archives.datapages.com/data/specpubs/beaumont/ch09/ch09.htm
Line 14: Line 14:
 
  | isbn    = 0-89181-602-X
 
  | isbn    = 0-89181-602-X
 
}}
 
}}
[[Pore systems|Pore type]], [[Pore system shapes|pore geometry]], and [[Petroleum reservoir fluid properties|fluid properties]] are critical factors affecting [[permeability]]. Sandstone texture directly affects pore type and geometry. Knowing what textures and fluids to expect, as well as what [[authigenic clay]]s might be present, can help us predict permeability.
+
[[Reservoir quality|Pore type]], [[Pore system shapes|pore geometry]], and [[Petroleum reservoir fluid properties|fluid properties]] are critical factors affecting [[permeability]]. Sandstone texture directly affects pore type and geometry. Knowing what textures and fluids to expect, as well as what [http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/authigenic authigenic] clays might be present, can help us predict permeability.
  
 
[[file:May2013BulletinCover.jpg|left|thumb|400px|Cliff-forming Wingate Sandstone, as seen from Upheaval Dome Road toward the Holeman Spring Canyon, Canyonlands National Park. Photo by Anita Torabi. Courtesy AAPG Bulletin.]]
 
[[file:May2013BulletinCover.jpg|left|thumb|400px|Cliff-forming Wingate Sandstone, as seen from Upheaval Dome Road toward the Holeman Spring Canyon, Canyonlands National Park. Photo by Anita Torabi. Courtesy AAPG Bulletin.]]
Line 20: Line 20:
  
 
==Effects of pore type and geometry==
 
==Effects of pore type and geometry==
Pore type, defined by [[Pore and pore throat sizes|pore throat size]] (i.e., macroporosity), directly controls rock [[permeability]]. Pore throat size limits [[Fundamentals of fluid flow|flow capacity]]. Pore geometry also affects permeability, but not as much. The rougher the surface of the pore, the more difficult for fluid to flow through the pore and the lower the permeability.
+
Pore type, defined by [[Pore and pore throat sizes|pore throat size]] (i.e., [http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/macroporous macroporosity]), directly controls rock [[permeability]]. Pore throat size limits [[Fundamentals of fluid flow|flow capacity]]. Pore geometry also affects permeability, but not as much. The rougher the surface of the pore, the more difficult for fluid to flow through the pore and the lower the permeability.
  
 
==Effects of texture==
 
==Effects of texture==
Line 35: Line 35:
  
 
==Rules of thumb for gas vs. oil==
 
==Rules of thumb for gas vs. oil==
Use the following rules of thumb for permeability for oil vs. gas reservoirs:
+
Use the following rules of thumb for [[permeability]] for oil vs. gas reservoirs:
  
 
* At >10 millidarcies (md), the [[reservoir]] can produce oil without [[stimulation]].
 
* At >10 millidarcies (md), the [[reservoir]] can produce oil without [[stimulation]].
Line 43: Line 43:
 
==Effect of authigenic clays==
 
==Effect of authigenic clays==
  
[[file:predicting-reservoir-system-quality-and-performance_fig9-61.png|300px|thumb|{{figure number|2}}. Copyright: F. K. North;<ref name=North_1985>North, F. K., 1985, Petroleum Geology: London, Allen & Unwin, 607 p.</ref> courtesy Allen & Unwin.]]
+
[[file:predicting-reservoir-system-quality-and-performance_fig9-61.png|300px|thumb|{{figure number|2}}Comparison of porosity-permeability relationships for kaolinite-, chlorite-, and illite-cemented sandstones. Copyright: F. K. North;<ref name=North_1985>North, F. K., 1985, Petroleum Geology: London, Allen & Unwin, 607 p.</ref> courtesy Allen & Unwin.]]
  
 
Pore-bridging clays, like [[illite]], decrease porosity slightly but can destroy sandstone [[permeability]]. Discrete particle clay, like [[kaolinite]], lowers [[porosity]] and permeability only slightly. [[:file:predicting-reservoir-system-quality-and-performance_fig9-61.png|Figure 2]] compares porosity-permeability relationships for kaolinite-, [[chlorite]]-, and illite-cemented sandstones. Note there is no significant change in porosities, but permeabilities range over four orders of magnitude.
 
Pore-bridging clays, like [[illite]], decrease porosity slightly but can destroy sandstone [[permeability]]. Discrete particle clay, like [[kaolinite]], lowers [[porosity]] and permeability only slightly. [[:file:predicting-reservoir-system-quality-and-performance_fig9-61.png|Figure 2]] compares porosity-permeability relationships for kaolinite-, [[chlorite]]-, and illite-cemented sandstones. Note there is no significant change in porosities, but permeabilities range over four orders of magnitude.
  
[[file:predicting-reservoir-system-quality-and-performance_fig9-62.png|thumb|300px|{{figure number|3}}After Neasham.<ref name=ch09r40>Neasham, J. W., 1977, The morphology of dispersed clay in sandstone reservoirs and its effect on sandstone shaliness, pore space, and fluid flow properties: Proceedings of the SPE Annual Meeting, October 9–12, paper SPE-6858.</ref> Copyright: SPE.]]
+
[[file:predicting-reservoir-system-quality-and-performance_fig9-62.png|thumb|300px|{{figure number|3}}Pore lining and discrete particle clays. After Neasham.<ref name=ch09r40>Neasham, J. W., 1977, The morphology of dispersed clay in sandstone reservoirs and its effect on sandstone shaliness, pore space, and fluid flow properties: Proceedings of the SPE Annual Meeting, October 9–12, paper SPE-6858.</ref> Copyright: SPE.]]
  
 
[[:file:predicting-reservoir-system-quality-and-performance_fig9-62.png|Figure 3]] shows pore lining and discrete particle clays that decrease porosity and permeability only slightly in contrast to pore-bridging clays, which decrease porosity slightly but substantially lower permeability.
 
[[:file:predicting-reservoir-system-quality-and-performance_fig9-62.png|Figure 3]] shows pore lining and discrete particle clays that decrease porosity and permeability only slightly in contrast to pore-bridging clays, which decrease porosity slightly but substantially lower permeability.
Line 53: Line 53:
 
==Detrital clay and permeability==
 
==Detrital clay and permeability==
  
[[file:predicting-reservoir-system-quality-and-performance_fig9-63.png|300px|thumb|{{figure number|4}}After Wilson and Pittman.<ref name=ch09r68>Wilson, M. D., Pittman, E. D., 1977, Authigenic clays in sandstones: recognition and influence on reservoir properties and [[paleoenvironmental analysis]]: Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, vol. 47, no. 1, p. 3–31.</ref> Copyright: Journal of Sedimentary Petrology.]]
+
[[file:predicting-reservoir-system-quality-and-performance_fig9-63.png|300px|thumb|{{figure number|4}}Types of detrital clays in a sandstone. After Wilson and Pittman.<ref name=ch09r68>Wilson, M. D., Pittman, E. D., 1977, Authigenic clays in sandstones: recognition and influence on reservoir properties and [[paleoenvironmental analysis]]: Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, vol. 47, no. 1, p. 3–31.</ref> Copyright: Journal of Sedimentary Petrology.]]
  
[[Detrital clay]]s can be part of sandstone matrix or grains. As matrix, detrital clays can obliterate permeability. Detrital grains of clay are often [[Ductility|ductile]] and can be compacted into pore spaces during burial. The percentage of detrital clay in a rock determines permeability. [[:file:predicting-reservoir-system-quality-and-performance_fig9-63.png|Figure 4]] shows different types of detrital clays in a sandstone.
+
[http://www.thefreedictionary.com/Detrital Detrital] clays can be part of sandstone [http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/369508/matrix matrix] or grains. As matrix, detrital clays can obliterate permeability. Detrital grains of clay are often [[Ductility|ductile]] and can be compacted into pore spaces during burial. The percentage of detrital clay in a rock determines [[permeability]]. [[:file:predicting-reservoir-system-quality-and-performance_fig9-63.png|Figure 4]] shows different types of detrital clays in a sandstone.
  
==Effect of quartz overgrowths==
+
==Effect of [[quartz]] overgrowths==
In general, as quartz cement precipitates, the pore:pore throat size ratio approaches 1.<ref name=Harris1985>Harris, P. M., C. G. St.-C. Kendall, and I. Lerche, 1985, Carbonate cementation—a brief review, in N. Schneidermann and P. M. Harris, eds., Carbonate Cements: SEPM Special Publication 36, p. 79–95.</ref> Throats are reduced less than pore space; therefore, [[permeability]] is affected less than porosity. During cementation, the size of the pore spaces between the pore-filling crystals decreases until it approaches the size of the pore throats. Throats become more tabular or sheet-like. Sandstone porosity may be quite low (<5%) and still have some permeability (<10 md) where cemented with quartz. (See also [[Connectivity and pore throat size]].)
+
In general, as quartz cement precipitates, the pore:pore throat size ratio approaches 1.<ref name=Harris1985>Harris, P. M., C. G. St.-C. Kendall, and I. Lerche, 1985, Carbonate cementation—a brief review, in N. Schneidermann and P. M. Harris, eds., Carbonate Cements: SEPM Special Publication 36, p. 79–95.</ref> Throats are reduced less than pore space; therefore, [[permeability]] is affected less than [[porosity]]. During cementation, the size of the pore spaces between the pore-filling crystals decreases until it approaches the size of the pore throats. Throats become more tabular or sheet-like. Sandstone porosity may be quite low (<5%) and still have some permeability (<10 md) where cemented with quartz. (See also [[Connectivity and pore throat size]].)
  
 
==Effect of fractures==
 
==Effect of fractures==
[[Fracture]]s enhance the permeability of any sandstone reservoir. Fractures are especially important for improving the permeability of sandstone reservoirs with abundant microporosity or disconnected dissolution porosity.
+
[[Fracture]]s enhance the [[permeability]] of any sandstone [[reservoir]]. Fractures are especially important for improving the permeability of sandstone reservoirs with abundant [Wikipedia:Microporous material microporosity] or disconnected dissolution porosity.
  
 
===Predicting from texture and clay content===
 
===Predicting from texture and clay content===
Predicting sandstone reservoir permeability is possible as long as we realize that potential errors may be large. Any process that decreases pore throat size decreases permeability, so predict accordingly. Use the table below to help predict sandstone reservoir permeability.
+
Predicting sandstone reservoir permeability is possible as long as we realize that potential errors may be large. Any process that decreases pore throat size decreases permeability, so predict accordingly. Use the procedure below to help predict sandstone reservoir permeability.
  
{| class = "wikitable"
+
# Estimate [[grain size]], [[Core_description#Maturity|sorting]], and [[porosity]] using the [[Depositional environments|depositional environment]]. For example, if a reservoir is a [[beach]] sand, it should be fine to medium grained and well sorted with well-rounded [[quartz]] grains
|-
+
# Apply information from Step 1 to the porosity–permeability–grain size plot ([[:file:predicting-reservoir-system-quality-and-performance_fig9-60.png|Figure 1]]). Use porosity and grain size from sandstone to estimate the permeability on the chart.
! Step
+
# If the sandstone is poorly sorted or is cemented, then discount permeability downward.
! Action
+
# Determine if [ http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/authigenicauthigenic] clay is present. If so, what kind: pore lining, discrete particle, or pore-throat bridging? Adjust permeability downward according to clay type present.
|-
+
# Determine if [http://www.thefreedictionary.com/Detrital detrital] clay is present using depositional environment (i.e., high energy = low clay content). If detrital clay is likely, then expect permeability to be low.
| 1
 
| Estimate [[grain size]], [[Core_description#Maturity|sorting]], and [[porosity]] using the [[depositional environment]]. For example, if a reservoir is a beach sand, it should be fine to medium grained and well sorted with well-rounded quartz grains
 
|-
 
| 2
 
| Apply information from Step 1 to the porosity–permeability–grain size plot ([[:file:predicting-reservoir-system-quality-and-performance_fig9-60.png|Figure 1]]). Use porosity and grain size from sandstone to estimate the permeability on the chart.
 
|-
 
| 3
 
| If the sandstone is poorly sorted or is cemented, then discount permeability downward.
 
|-
 
| 4
 
| Determine if authigenic clay is present. If so, what kind: pore lining, discrete particle, or pore-throat bridging? Adjust permeability downward according to clay type present.
 
|-
 
| 5
 
| Determine if detrital clay is present using depositional environment (i.e., high energy = low clay content). If detrital clay is likely, then expect permeability to be low.
 
|}
 
  
 
==See also==
 
==See also==
Line 95: Line 80:
 
* [[Predicting sandstone reservoir porosity]]
 
* [[Predicting sandstone reservoir porosity]]
 
* [[Estimating sandstone permeability from cuttings]]
 
* [[Estimating sandstone permeability from cuttings]]
* [[Connectivity and pore throat size]]
+
* [[Pore throat size and connectivity]]
  
 
==References==
 
==References==
Line 107: Line 92:
 
[[Category:Predicting the occurrence of oil and gas traps]]  
 
[[Category:Predicting the occurrence of oil and gas traps]]  
 
[[Category:Predicting reservoir system quality and performance]]
 
[[Category:Predicting reservoir system quality and performance]]
 +
[[Category:Treatise Handbook 3]]

Latest revision as of 17:03, 6 April 2022

Exploring for Oil and Gas Traps
Series Treatise in Petroleum Geology
Part Predicting the occurrence of oil and gas traps
Chapter Predicting reservoir system quality and performance
Author Dan J. Hartmann, Edward A. Beaumont
Link Web page
Store AAPG Store

Pore type, pore geometry, and fluid properties are critical factors affecting permeability. Sandstone texture directly affects pore type and geometry. Knowing what textures and fluids to expect, as well as what authigenic clays might be present, can help us predict permeability.

Cliff-forming Wingate Sandstone, as seen from Upheaval Dome Road toward the Holeman Spring Canyon, Canyonlands National Park. Photo by Anita Torabi. Courtesy AAPG Bulletin.

Effects of pore type and geometry

Pore type, defined by pore throat size (i.e., macroporosity), directly controls rock permeability. Pore throat size limits flow capacity. Pore geometry also affects permeability, but not as much. The rougher the surface of the pore, the more difficult for fluid to flow through the pore and the lower the permeability.

Effects of texture

Figure 1 Grain size affects permeability and porosity.[1]

Sandstone texture affects permeability as follows:

  • Decreasing grain size decreases permeability.
  • Increasing grain sorting increases permeability.
  • Increasing grain rounding increases permeability.

Figure 1 shows how grain size affects permeability and porosity.

Rules of thumb for gas vs. oil

Use the following rules of thumb for permeability for oil vs. gas reservoirs:

  • At >10 millidarcies (md), the reservoir can produce oil without stimulation.
  • At >1 md, the reservoir can produce gas without stimulation.
  • At 1–10 md, the reservoir probably requires stimulation for oil production.

Effect of authigenic clays

Figure 2 Comparison of porosity-permeability relationships for kaolinite-, chlorite-, and illite-cemented sandstones. Copyright: F. K. North;[2] courtesy Allen & Unwin.

Pore-bridging clays, like illite, decrease porosity slightly but can destroy sandstone permeability. Discrete particle clay, like kaolinite, lowers porosity and permeability only slightly. Figure 2 compares porosity-permeability relationships for kaolinite-, chlorite-, and illite-cemented sandstones. Note there is no significant change in porosities, but permeabilities range over four orders of magnitude.

Figure 3 Pore lining and discrete particle clays. After Neasham.[3] Copyright: SPE.

Figure 3 shows pore lining and discrete particle clays that decrease porosity and permeability only slightly in contrast to pore-bridging clays, which decrease porosity slightly but substantially lower permeability.

Detrital clay and permeability

Figure 4 Types of detrital clays in a sandstone. After Wilson and Pittman.[4] Copyright: Journal of Sedimentary Petrology.

Detrital clays can be part of sandstone matrix or grains. As matrix, detrital clays can obliterate permeability. Detrital grains of clay are often ductile and can be compacted into pore spaces during burial. The percentage of detrital clay in a rock determines permeability. Figure 4 shows different types of detrital clays in a sandstone.

Effect of quartz overgrowths

In general, as quartz cement precipitates, the pore:pore throat size ratio approaches 1.[5] Throats are reduced less than pore space; therefore, permeability is affected less than porosity. During cementation, the size of the pore spaces between the pore-filling crystals decreases until it approaches the size of the pore throats. Throats become more tabular or sheet-like. Sandstone porosity may be quite low (<5%) and still have some permeability (<10 md) where cemented with quartz. (See also Connectivity and pore throat size.)

Effect of fractures

Fractures enhance the permeability of any sandstone reservoir. Fractures are especially important for improving the permeability of sandstone reservoirs with abundant [Wikipedia:Microporous material microporosity] or disconnected dissolution porosity.

Predicting from texture and clay content

Predicting sandstone reservoir permeability is possible as long as we realize that potential errors may be large. Any process that decreases pore throat size decreases permeability, so predict accordingly. Use the procedure below to help predict sandstone reservoir permeability.

  1. Estimate grain size, sorting, and porosity using the depositional environment. For example, if a reservoir is a beach sand, it should be fine to medium grained and well sorted with well-rounded quartz grains
  2. Apply information from Step 1 to the porosity–permeability–grain size plot (Figure 1). Use porosity and grain size from sandstone to estimate the permeability on the chart.
  3. If the sandstone is poorly sorted or is cemented, then discount permeability downward.
  4. Determine if [ http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/authigenicauthigenic] clay is present. If so, what kind: pore lining, discrete particle, or pore-throat bridging? Adjust permeability downward according to clay type present.
  5. Determine if detrital clay is present using depositional environment (i.e., high energy = low clay content). If detrital clay is likely, then expect permeability to be low.

See also

References

  1. Coalson, E. B., Hartmann, D. J., and Thomas, J. B., 1990, Applied Petrophysics in Exploration and Exploitation: Notes from short course sponsored by Univ. of Colorado–Denver, var. pages.
  2. North, F. K., 1985, Petroleum Geology: London, Allen & Unwin, 607 p.
  3. Neasham, J. W., 1977, The morphology of dispersed clay in sandstone reservoirs and its effect on sandstone shaliness, pore space, and fluid flow properties: Proceedings of the SPE Annual Meeting, October 9–12, paper SPE-6858.
  4. Wilson, M. D., Pittman, E. D., 1977, Authigenic clays in sandstones: recognition and influence on reservoir properties and paleoenvironmental analysis: Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, vol. 47, no. 1, p. 3–31.
  5. Harris, P. M., C. G. St.-C. Kendall, and I. Lerche, 1985, Carbonate cementation—a brief review, in N. Schneidermann and P. M. Harris, eds., Carbonate Cements: SEPM Special Publication 36, p. 79–95.

External links

find literature about
Sandstone permeability prediction from texture
Datapages button.png GeoScienceWorld button.png OnePetro button.png Google button.png